We have recently published our first annual Healthcare Recruitment Benchmark study. A core piece of the study was measuring/benchmarking key process efficiency metrics of the staffing supply chain.
Through this initiative, we found the average Route to Hire Efficiency Metric to be 6.7 to 1.
That is, it takes 6.7 candidates routed to the hiring manager to achieve 1 hire. While this actually is pretty darn efficient compared to studies we have done in other industries, Best in Class organizations (representing the average of the top 25%) Route to Hire Efficiency was 2.48 to 1!
Basically, the Elite, efficient organizations required half as many candidates (routed) to get 1 hire!
Or course there are/were many things they did differently to develop a Lean, efficient staffing process, but something all systems had in common was this concept of Time, Tenure and Trust.
- Time – All Elite organizations spend a considerable amount of time on:
- The intake session with the hiring manager. They made sure they clearly understood the need, how to market the opportunity; define clear service levels for service, etc.
- The pre-screen process. Whether they used an automated assessment tool and/or some combination of phone interview, they spent enough time with the candidate to ensure they were someone that was worthy of consideration and should be interviewed by the hiring manager.
- Discussing candidates with managers and proactively setting interviews.
While all these steps might seem obvious to some experienced recruiters, many recruiters/organizations still struggle to INVEST the time required in these three steps. The usual results include routing too many candidates to managers that they in return reject to be interviewed/considered. This is clearly evident in that the average Route to Hiring Manager efficiency was 43% while the Elite organizations efficiency was 80%!
- Tenure – Most Elite firms agreed that they had many ‘tenured’ recruiters on staff that had built rapport with their hiring managers, taken the time to understand the business unit they supported, etc. All firms agreed that you can overcome short tenure by investing the time in the three steps above.
- Trust – Elite recruiters have the trust of the hiring managers and they respect them as staffing consultants.
- They interview the candidates the recruiters send rather than scrutinize!
- They ask for their opinion when deciding on making an offer (or not).
- They respect their input on compensation discussions.
While I don’t want to over simplify how the Elite organizations have become hyper efficient, I don’t want to lose the forest through the trees either! Time invested up front can quickly turn a non-tenured recruiter into a staffing consultant that garners a ton of TRUST FROM their hiring managers.
Some food for thought on a Wednesday!
PS – If you are a healthcare organization that wants more information on our Healthcare Recruitment Benchmark Study, please contact us!





